In September 1994, when I was 18 years old, I started my undergraduate degree at Napier University in Edinburgh – in a case of ‘stating the obvious’, that was thirty years ago. I am now 48 years old.
As a fresh-faced, straight-outta-school student, I recall being somewhat surprised to learn that my cohort included students of varying ages—some even in their late 30s (insert shock-horror expression). At the time, and from a place of ignorance and naivety, I remember questioning why someone would start an undergrad when they were so old. Surely actual adults did post-graduate stuff, like PhDs? I remember the older students gravitated towards each other during those first few weeks, and things stayed the same for most of the succeeding four years. From my perspective, it seemed like they felt as if they didn’t quite fit in.
Fast-forward the almost 30 years mentioned above. In September 2023, I started my PhD at Queen Margaret University in Edinburgh. I was surprised to learn that my cohort was a mix of students of various ages but much younger than me. I was wrong; old(er) people are not the only ones who did stuff like PhDs, and this time round, I was the one who felt as if I didn’t quite fit in.
There is a difference, of course, between undergrad and PhDs. For the most part, we are on our own journey with the latter. We’re not corralled as a collective into lecture halls or huddled into seminar rooms, nor are we subjected to the mandatory group work project (which is the very best prep for working life, especially if you don’t get to pick your group); no, with the PhD we only formally come together for three weeks per year for our development sessions and informally if a few of us happen to be in the library or cafe.
However, during these infrequent times of togetherness, I feel my oldest, and during (and after) these times of togetherness, I reflect on my challenges and perhaps the benefits I experience as an older student.
Young students, especially those who have gone from undergrad to master’s to PhD without time in the world of work, benefit from an academic focus in their thinking. Of course, they don’t know anything else, so they are highly tuned into all aspects of academia and quick, too. Reading, analysing, evaluating, recalling, articulating, writing, and referencing – they appear to do it all with an enviable ease. In contrast, it is as if I have to make a laboured conscious shift in track to get my academic train of thought moving.